Skip to content

2016 Best Tasting Irish Cream Liqueurs

mollys-pour-shotWhat are the best tasting Irish Cream Liqueurs?  Before we get started lets start at the beginning.  In 1971 a group of managers at Gilbeys had an idea to create a unique Irish drink to sell to the International market.  By 1974 they had developed a process of combining fresh dairy cream with alcohol while still providing a 2 year shelf life.  This product Baileys Irish Cream Liqueur launched an entire new spirit category.  Today there are cream liqueurs made with rum, bourbon, scotch, vodka, and even tequila.  With hundreds of cream liqueurs now available Baileys still remains the best selling Irish cream liqueur and one of the worlds best selling spirits.  That said there are now over 100 Irish Cream Liqueurs produced today.  Believe it or not all of these Irish creams are produced at six or seven distillery’s in Ireland.  While I haven’t tasted every Irish cream liqueur, dozens are not offered for sale in North America, I have tried over 60, and reviewed over 50.  There may be someone who has sampled more Irish Creams, but I have seen no one review more.  I also like Irish Cream Liqueurs, to some reviewers, Irish Cream is just another spirit to review.  These fact alone make Best Tasting Spirits a leading source for Irish Cream reviews.  I feel the large sample size and the consistency of only one reviewer increases the accuracy of this list, but in the end it comes down to one mans opinion.  So what are the Best Tasting Irish Creams, and what makes them special?   

Read more

Recent Articles


Review: Tullamore DEW XO Caribbean Rum Cask Finish

Tullamore DEW XO Caribbean Rum Cask Finish is made with the same recipe as Tullamore DEW Original.  It is triple distilled and a triple blend of pot still, malt and grain Irish whiskey.  The whiskey is finished in first fill XO rum casks previously used to age Demerara rum.  Tullamore DEW XO Caribbean Rum Cask Finish pays tribute to the role of Irish immigrants in the development of rum in the Caribbean in the 17th century.  This is not the first Tullamore DEW finished in a second cask.  They also produce Tullamore DEW Cider Cask Finish. Read more »


Review: Two Founders 80 Acres Vodka

Two Founders 80 Acres Vodka was recently released.  I found my bottle at Total Wine and More.  Two Founders is one of several vodka varieties that are bottled in Princeton Minnesota that I only seem to find at Total Wine and More stores.  Two Founders is made from corn grown in Iowa, presumable on an 80 acre farm.  The spirit is distilled five times in Iowa before heading to Princeton Minnesota to be bottled at 80 proof.    Read more »


Review: Bacardi 8 Anos Rum

Bacardi 8 Anos Rum was originally created in 1862.  It was the exclusive party rum of the Bacardi family for over 130 years, and still today it only exists in very limited stock.  The Bacardi Company got its start when Don Facundo Bacardi Masso purchased a distillery in 1862 in Cuba for 3500 pesos.  They continued producing rum in Cuba until 1960 when their distillery was seized as part of the Cuban Revolution.  Since then they have been distilling their rum in Puerto Rico.  This molasses based rum is fermented with a single strain of yeast, Le Levadura Bacardi.  After distilling, the spirit is aged for a minimum 8 years in oak barrels, and then blended by their Master Blender. Read more »


Review: Powers Gold Label Irish Whiskey

Powers Gold Label Irish Whiskey is a brand that has been around since 1886 when John Power and Son Distillery began bottling this whiskey with a gold label.  Until then casks of whiskey were sold to merchants and bonders who would bottle the whiskey.  The Powers Gold Label Irish Whiskey produced today is a blend of triple distilled pot still whiskey and grain whiskey.  Both are matured in American oak casks, non chill filtered, blended, and bottled at 86.4 proof.  The previous version was chill filtered and weighed in at 80 proof.  To see my thoughts on Powers Gold Label 80 Proof, check out yesterdays review.      Read more »


Review: Powers Gold Label Irish Whiskey 80 Proof

Powers Gold Label Irish Whiskey 80 proof is no longer produced for the US market.  It appears it is still available for sale in Ireland.  In December 2013 Powers Gold Label was rebranded and reformulated with new packaging and an increased 86.4 proof.  This was accomplished by eliminating the use of chill filtration.  This was the second reformulation of the brand which started life as a single pot still whiskey but was reinvented as a blend of pot still whiskey and grain whiskey many years ago.  I was lucky enough to have an unopened bottle of the 80 proof to compare with the new 86.4 proof Powers Gold Label.  Look for that review tomorrow.  James Power founded his distillery in 1791 at John Lane near the western gate of Dublin City.  By 1821 his son John changed the name to John Power and Son. In 1886 Powers began bottling their whiskey with a gold Label on the bottle, becoming the first Dublin distiller to bottle their own whiskey.  Soon this became known as Powers Gold Label Irish Whiskey.  In 1975 distillation moved to Midleton Ireland with the merger of John Power and Son, John Jameson and Son, and Cork Distilleries Company.  Powers Gold Label is made from a blend of triple distilled pot still and grain whiskey.  Both are aged in American oak casks, chill filtered, blending, and bottling at 80 proof.   Read more »


Review: Knappogue Castle 12 Year Old Irish Whiskey

Knappogue Castle 12 Year Old Irish Whiskey is made with pure Irish spring water and malted barley.  It is triple distilled from a single barley malt in copper pot stills and aged for a minimum of 12 years in bourbon oak casks.  The brand is named after the Knappogue Castle that was originally built in 1467.  Knappogue translates to, Hill of the kiss.  In 1966 Mark Edwin Andrews purchased the castle which at the time was in ruins.  He and his wife, a prominent architect embarked on an ambitious task of restoring the structure to it’s original state of glory and grandeur.  At that time Mark also began buying casks of fine pot still whiskey from top distilleries in Ireland.  The casks were further aged and bottled under the Knappogue Castle label.  In 2003 Castle Brands acquired the brand and in 2010 they launched Knappogue Castle 12 Year Old Irish Whiskey. Read more »


Review: Tullamore DEW Irish Whiskey

Tullamore DEW Irish Whiskey is named for the town and distillery where the whiskey was first produced, and the initials of Daniel E. Williams, who worked his way up from stable boy of the distillery to become the owner.  The Original Tullamore Distillery was opened in 1829 by Michael Molloy in the heart of the town of Tullamore.  The Tullamore Distillery closed its doors in the 1950’s and the brand was sold to John Power and Son in the 1960’s.  With the merger of John Power and Son, John Jameson and Son, and Cork Distilleries, production was moved to the New Midleton Distillery.  In 2010 the Tullamore brand was sold to William Grant and Sons.  After 60 years, production returned to the town of Tullamore with the opening of the brand new Tullamore Distillery.  Tullamore DEW is produced with all three types of Irish Whiskey, single grain, single malt, and pot still.  The whiskey is triple distilled and aged in three different types of oak barrels.  Traditional refill, ex bourbon, and ex sherry.  While whiskey produced at this distillery matures, Tullamore DEW continues to be made with single grain and pot-still whiskey distilled at the New Midleton Distillery, and single malt whiskey distilled by Bushmill.     Read more »


Review: Straw Boys Irish Vodka

Straw Boys Irish Vodka was launched in 2015.  It is crafted at the Connacht Distillery that sits on the banks of the River Moy.  The Connacht Whiskey Company is the result of a dream shared by four men, three Americans, and one Irishman, to bring pure pot still Irish whiskey back to the west of Ireland after a 100 year absence.  While they wait for their own produced whiskey to mature they have sourced Irish whiskey distilled from a secondary source, and they craft a gin, poitin, and vodka.  The Straw Boys name comes from an age old tradition in Ireland where a fun bunch of young men appear suddenly at a wedding to dance with the bride and groom.  They depart as swiftly as they arrived.  Their name comes from the straw hats used to hide their identity.  Their appearance is said to bring good fortune.  Straw Boys Irish Vodka is created using select wheat and is batch distilled in copper pot stills and hand bottled at the distillery. Read more »


Review: Green Spot Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey

Green Spot Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey is a non age statement pot still Irish whiskey comprised of Pot Still whiskeys aged between 7 and 10 years.  The whiskey has matured in a combination of new bourbon barrels, refill bourbon casks, and sherry casks.  Green Spot was originally created by the Mitchell family who in 1805 commenced trading in the heart of Dublin as purveyors of confectionary, wines, and fortified wines.  In 1887 the family expanded into the whiskey bonding business.  They sent empty wine, sherry, and port casks via horse and cart to the local Jameson Distillery.  These casks were filled with whiskey and returned to the Mitchells cellar warehouse where the whiskey matured for many years.  The Mitchells sold a range of whiskey under the Spot brand name.  This name originated from the practice of marking casks of different ages with a spot of colored paint.  There was Blue Spot, Red Spot, Yellow Spot, and their most popular Green Spot.  A limited number of bottles are produced each year, and until recently Green Spot was only available in Ireland.  Read more »


Review: Captain Morgan Watermelon Smash

Captain Morgan Watermelon Smash was just released.  This is the fourth cannon ball shaped variety of rum in the Captain Morgan stable of rum.  The others include Cannon Blast, Jack-O-Blast, and Loconut.  These flavors weighs in at 70, 60, and 40 proof.  Captain Morgan Watermelon Smash hits the scale at 50 proof.  All are designed to be enjoyed as a chilled shot or mixed in a tasty cocktail.  Watermelon Smash is made with rum distilled in St Croix.  Natural flavors and certified colors are blended with the rum upon its arrival in the US.  How much watermelon flavor does the Captain pack into this rum?  I could smell the watermelon from the shelf the bottle sat on.  Maybe because the bottles label is watermelon scented, or maybe because there is just too much watermelon flavor to contain in one bottle.  Read more »